No Image Available

Austin Swain

Read more about Austin Swain

The leadership required to forge a coalition government

pp_default1

While political power talks continue and we wait to see if we will be offered a coalition, multi-party deal or minority government, Austin Swain considers the leadership skills needed to forge a strong, workable, multi-party parliament.

 

The political landscape has shifted beyond recognition in the last 10 days. Clegg, Brown and Cameron have moved from tightly fought political debates to earnest attempts to resolve conflict and reach a resolution. The trio’s televised debates showcased differing opinions and seemingly incompatible leadership approaches. But the public has spoken and they want change. With the leaders’ differences rather than similarities capturing the headlines before May 6, how will collaboration truly materialise?

The first thing they’ll need to do is find common ground and focus on the higher goal in which they both have a vested interest and passion to achieve. This will set the tone for their conversations and provide something motivating to work towards. Disagreements will need to be acknowledged but sidelined in the short-term if they are seeking to really collaborate effectively. Relationships need to be built in the first instance and leaders will need to move away from their typical communication styles which centre on ‘advocacy’ – in other words, convincing somebody that their point of view is the right one, to ‘inquiry’ where they seek to truly understand another’s point of view, rather than criticise it.

The right balance of advocacy and inquiry will allow leaders to come to a third place or solution that they might not have thought about before. They’ll need to talk plainly, suspend judgements, listen properly and respect one another’s positions to reach common ground. They’ll also need to probe for other’s point of view, while encouraging people to challenge their own – a world away from much of the campaign trail which was rife with opposing views.

Traditionally, conflict is viewed as negative, destructive and something to be avoided. But actually, if people’s conflict is managed skilfully, it can be a positive force when it comes to collaboration. Without different views, teams can lack innovation, often becoming stale and unresponsive to change. This is an opportunity that any leadership coalition must recognise and seize.

After listening to each other’s views properly, they can search for outcomes that benefit both parties and, most importantly, the public who’ve asked for change. By merging two parties’ differing views, solutions have the potential to address the concerns of more of the British public. For whoever takes the number 10 keys, moving from competing to collaborating will mean being more accommodating and compromising.

Austin Swain is director of research and product at Lane4

2 Responses

  1. Coalitions are not teams

     Some of the messages coming from the new government emphasise the importance of becoming a team. This is dangerous in the longer term. Often when organisations decide to partner for whatever reason, the first act is to do likewise and aim to form ‘one team’. 

    Partnerships, like coalitions and arrangements between different groups with different values and some different objectives. Clegg and Cameron will need to emphasise the differences in their organisations as much as their similarities if they are to create a partnership that can deliver more than the some of the parts and  can be sustained in the longer term. the hardest part of the leaders will be to bring along their own people – the message must be to collaborate where the benefit is obvious to all parties but to keep separate in all other areas.

  2. The leadership requirements of coalition government

     The point about leaders of a coalition government needing to move from ‘advocacy’ to ‘inquiry’ in terms of their communication style is well made. But a change of communication style is not the only shift that Cameron Clegg and their new cabinet will have to make. Leaders of political coalitions like leaders of alliances or consortia in the private sector need to develop a whole new approach to collaborative leader ship if they are to; handle conflict, share control and build lasting relationships.  There are plenty of good examples out there to learn from (see for example http://www.thersa.org/fellowship/journal/archive/spring-2009/features/collaborative-leadership-in-times-of-change)

    I’d suggest six attributes that collaborative leaders need to develop their capabilities in:

    ·     Agility – quick to think through options, comfortable with handling complexity

    ·     Patience – acts as a calm and measured manner and imparts confidence

    ·     Collective decision making – involving others and explain rationale behind decisions

    ·     Empathy – aware of their personal impact and listens to understand the views of others

    ·     Handling conflict – constructively tackling conflict situations as soon as they appear

    ·     Building relationships – challenges the sceptics and actively builds strong networks

    Measured against this yardstick I think Cameron and Clegg have both made a decent start – for the good of the country they need to make it last.

Newsletter

Get the latest from HRZone

Subscribe to expert insights on how to create a better workplace for both your business and its people.

 

Thank you.