How can hybrid working work well?
Hybrid working has been much talked about of late, but how can employers get the most out of it?
The problem is that we are all still in the experimental stages and it takes a while for good practice to emerge, but it's interesting to look at what those who have been leading on smart working over the last years have to say and what leading employers are doing.
A WM People white paper based on a roundtable with major employers from local government to retail, finance and transport, among others, provided some food for thought. Andy Lake, editor of Flexibility.co.uk who runs the Smart Work Network, questioned the hybrid concept and said it can come across as the same world of work in a different place, the same culture and the same advice that was given out when teleworking was introduced in the 1990s. What is missing is the sense of transformation, he said. He highlighted concerns about employers making hybrid working too rigid rather than a dynamic, fluid process. He also highlighted the focus on desks and booking systems and on meeting rooms which seemed to be just about stretching the norms of the traditional office to an online space, he said.
Instead, employers should start with what can be done better and question when, where and how a work activity should be done in a way that makes work better. The principle should be to design the work then design the workplace, said Lake.
Employers at the roundtable, sponsored by remote working organisation Sensée, discussed a range of issues, from what offices are for in the hybrid world to the dangers of creating a ‘them and us’ situation of home workers and the rest. They said this needed a lot of thought and attention to how other workers could be offered flexibility and greater autonomy.
What about the impact on office estate? Lake said there were indications that the office will shrink as more people work remotely or only part time in the office. It is therefore important, he said, to get away from traditional ideas of desk spaces and meeting spaces. Employers need to think of everyone being equally remote rather than of remote and office workers and focus on quick, dynamic interactions rather than formal meetings, meetings in outdoor spaces on indoor/outdoor spaces like pods in a work cafe. The emphasis should be on teamwork and focus work spaces rather than booking a desk for the day, on what is needed to do a specific task and there should be a fluid movement between them.
Employers also discussed how people processes, including induction, line management and meetings need to change in the light of hybrid working, with managers being trained to manage on outcomes rather than presence.
Rob Hopkin is co-founder of Axis, a virtual collaboration platform designed to help organisations harness the power of diverse teams through inclusive, engaging and effective workshops and meetings. He said most organisations are looking to harness the talents of diverse teams to solve tricky problems, but meetings are not always the best way to do this. People often don’t listen in meetings, they encourage groupthink, the person who speaks loudest dominates [often with implications for gender equality], etc. This is corrosive to the rest of the team’s sense of engagement and the organisation’s ability to innovate. Lockdown had levelled the playing field more as many people had to work remotely, but doing everything over a Zoom call can worsen engagement, with some people dominating even more.
Axis is working to create more effective, inclusive collaborative environments, which don’t just rely on who has the loudest voice. That means using other ways than talking to get information across in group settings, giving time for people to digest information and recognising that some need longer than others and polling them in meetings so decision-making is more collective.
Key takeaways from the discussion included the following:
- Start with tasks and what can be done better
- Keep everything dynamic and avoid rigid processes
- Design the work and then the workplace
- Question traditional views about how things work
- Think of everyone being equally remote
- Recruit for hybrid workers with an emphasis on empathy
- Use buddies to support new remote recruits and video learning
- Enlist team members to discuss remote induction processes
- Realise that the role of line manager is more important in hybrid working in terms of addressing things like isolation and train managers for the skills they need.
All are valuable things to consider, but what came across strongly was the need for a leadership and a strategic approach to hybrid working. It is not good enough to simply export office systems to a remote landscape. Hybrid working requires much deeper change, starting with mindset.
Mandy Garner is managing editor of workingmums.co.uk and workingwise.co.uk. workingmums.co.uk is a jobs and news site on issues relating to gender equality and family friendly working and workingwise.co.uk focuses on over 50s.